Residential Security Systems: Manned Guardingvs Technology

In this article, we will critically analyse the advantages and disadvantages of technology security solutions versus manned guarding services. Many people are wondering whether residential security systems should still include a manned component, or whether a smart technology solution is efficient on its own. By analysing the advantages and disadvantages of each solution, we can successfully conclude which application would be more effective, or whether a hybrid solution is more viable.

Let’s have a look at how we can create the perfect residential security solution, which elements should be used, and which can quickly be left behind.

The Advantages of Manned Guarding

As with all solutions, each has its own set of advantages. Manned guarding services have been around for decades, traceable back to the Vigiles of ancient Rome. However, back to 2019, here are the advantages that still exist with manned guarding services today:

• Manned guards can use all their senses to detect a breach, they will usually be able to hear a trespasser before seeing one.
• Security guarding officials can provide inspection services as well as general management solutions.
• Manned guards can respond to other emergencies, such as utility faults.
• Manned guards act as a visual deterrent, warding many potential trespassers away by making their presence known.
• Manned guards can also act as a further deterrent when using a guard dog. A guard dog will intimidate people and will also sense a trespasser before it’s too late.

The Disadvantages of Manned Guarding

There are disadvantages to every solution, here are the disadvantages that may apply with a security solution that purely revolves around manned guarding:

• Hiring a 24/7 manned security service can be costly.
• A guard can only be at one place at one time.
• An audit system is required to successfully manage regular patrols.

The Advantages of a Technology Security Solution

Technology security solutions, such as IPsec, are growing in popularity in today’s day and age, and they definitely do have a lot of advantages. The advantages of a tech-savvy residential security solution include:

• Many cameras and devices can be fitted around the property which allows for several “eyes” to watch the property at once.
• Alarms attentively monitor 24/7.
• These systems can be more cost-effective when compared to the labour cost of security officials.
• CCTV can capture all happenings for reactive monitoring.

The Disadvantages of a Technology Security Solution

A residential security system which is limited to a technology-only solution has its disadvantages, these include:

• If there is no residential security monitoring service to go together with the technology, no action will be taken when it matters most.
• A technology system may be less of a deterrent on the property than when a guard is seen.
• If a technology system is not properly backed-up, they may lose power and cause downtime in surveillance.

The Conclusion?

As seen above, each solution on its own has a few advantages, but they also have a couple of disadvantages. At Apache Security Services, we merge these services and applications into one effective security solution to counteract the disadvantages of each and retain all the advantages. A hybrid solution that consists of manned services, as well as technology security devices deployed onsite, will enable you to get the best of both worlds to maximise the security of your property. Using our CCTV installation services, you can get the technology you need, and with our offsite residential security monitoring services, you can get the advantages of having a security official assigned to ensuring the safety of your home.

The fact remains, security officials are still very much required for today’s residential security systems. However, by pairing these teams with smart technology systems, a better security solution can be designed. A security solution that takes the power of human intelligence and capability and merges it with powerful and scalable technology.